• The ultimate aim is to produce 800kg of milk solids a cow

    Chris Stockdale Allerston Near Pickering

    NIS helps manage tight forage stocks and maintain butterfat.

    Contact Us

NIS helps manage tight forage stocks and maintain butterfat

Changing how he adds fibre to his rations has helped one North Yorkshire dairy farmer make the most of tight silage stocks and optimise his milk contract.

For Chris Stockdale, running the 170-cow dairy unit within his family’s diversified business at Allerston near Pickering in North Yorkshire takes careful management. The other enterprises on the 470 acre farm – including combinable crops and a 250-bay caravan site – mean Chris always has limited amounts of land available to him for growing forage.

The family has nearly paid off the investment they made seven years ago in a new parlour and housing, and Chris feels optimistic that the business is in good shape, especially as prices now seem to be on the turn. His pedigree Holstein Carrvale herd is currently averaging 9,700kg per cow at 4.17% butterfat, with 3,800kg coming from forage. But as part of his effort to keep costs down, Chris is keen to reach a clear 4,000kg from forage rather than push for total yield.

If the cows creep up to 10,000kg without trying, then that’s fine, but how we do it is more important,” he explains. “Getting that extra milk from forage rather than concentrate is cheaper. We also can’t afford to sacrifice butterfat on our Arla standard contract.


So we feed our maize silage strategically, when we can and when we need to, stretching it out with other forages. We’ve increased the amount of wholecrop we make to partly compensate and have also had unsuccessful attempts to add straw. Chopping it to the length we want in the TMR, around 2cm, means the rest of the ration ingredients get over-processed.

But working with Chris Lyth from Thompson’s Feeds, Chris found a way last winter to get more fibre into the diet through nutritionally improved straw (NIS) – alkali-treated and pelleted chopped straw.

“At the beginning of housing we hit a problem when we ran out of maize. We started feeding first cut, taken early in mid-May when the grass was short, lush, very high in sugars and low in NDF. It proved a little too ‘fiery’ for the cows and they struggled to keep it inside them. Dung was very loose and we couldn’t get the cows to settle.

“At this point we would normally have increased maize silage in the diet but we had none left, and with maize harvest last year ending up as late as grass was early, we weren’t going to be able to feed that year’s crop until nearer Christmas. We tried chopping and adding a kg of straw alongside the kg of hay we already had in the ration, and increasing sugarbeet pulp, but a month went by and things hadn’t really improved.”

At this point, Chris Lyth secured five tonnes of NIS on a trial basis, and the duo initially mixed it into TMR at 1.5kg per cow, increasing to 2kg shortly after.

Chris Lyth picks up the story: “Pretty quickly, the cows started calming down,” he says. “Digestion seemed to stabilise and dung became firmer. We carried on using NIS in the ration to balance the grass silage until the maize silage was ready to feed, at which point we cut it back to 1.5kg in the high group.

“Then at turnout this year and mindful of Arla’s component-based contract, we decided Chris should cut back on maize to preserve stocks and reintroduce NIS in the buffer-fed TMR at 2kg as a precautionary step to stabilise butterfat.”

Chris Lyth reports that with cows averaging 29kg at 4.11% fat before turnout, he was pleased to see average yields move up to 31-32kg with butterfat levels holding at over 4%. Through April, May and June, the lowest butterfat dipped to was 3.95% but yields were maintained and the cows came back to averaging 32-33kg a day at 4% butterfat.

However, with one problem solved, he says the other challenge was maintaining the high yielders at an average yield of around 45kg daily. “With the arable operations Chris and his family have, it makes sense to feed as much home-grown cereal as possible, but this too has an impact on rumen health despite the grain being ammonia-treated,” he explains.

“Again, NIS has proved a really useful tool. The high yielders have been maintaining yield and condition on 1.5kg of NIS plus 15kg maize silage freshweight mixed into the TMR. With stocks running low again, maize silage will soon have to be scaled back to conserve stocks, but then there’s the option of increasing NIS to maintain rumen stability and butterfat. The impact on rumen health has been the big driver to use straw in the form of NIS, and that has had an impact on yield per cow per day which in turn drives kgs fat sold.”

Chris Stockdale agrees. He says: “Using NIS to keep butterfat yields consistent and balance the ration as we switch around forages is certainly a better option than either chopped straw, which has no feed value and ends up ‘dumbing down’ the ration, or C16 fat, which at £800+ per tonne costs us over 30p per cow per day to feed compared with NIS at 13.6p/kg.”

The other development is that since turnout, the low yielders have been buffer-fed TMR as a supplement to the base diet rather than a replacement, with the aim of increasing grass intakes. Issues with getting enough fibre into the diet have been solved by including NIS in the buffer TMR here as well.

Chris Lyth says: “Inconsistency in intake increases as a problem as grazing forms an ever-larger part of the diet. We can’t control temperature, daylight hours and rainfall, and all these affect sugar and fibre levels. So NIS is an easy way of balancing this out. I’ve started using it mixed into the parlour cake on other farms, at a ratio of five parts cake to one part NIS, and it’s worked really well in terms of rumen health and production.”


Get in Touch

If you have a question about any of our products please contact us on +44 (0)1480 860 745 and a member of our team will be more than happy to help.

Contact Us